Fourth Circuit Backs Maryland in Kalshi Dispute
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled on Wednesday that Maryland retains the authority to regulate Kalshi under its state sports-wagering laws, marking another significant legal hurdle for the prediction market industry. In a 2-1 decision, the appellate court determined that Congress did not clearly displace Maryland's concurrent authority over gambling. Judge Roger Gregory wrote that gambling regulation has long been a matter of traditional state police power, Jesse Hamilton at CoinDesk reported.
Following the ruling, Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown stated that Kalshi must adhere to the state's consumer protection standards, which include safeguarding customer data and halting marketing to individuals at risk of gambling harm. A Kalshi spokesperson argued that the splintered decision highlights a lack of a unified legal argument against prediction markets. However, this marks the third out of four appellate decisions that have ruled in favor of state oversight, creating a direct conflict with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission's (CFTC) recent 30-day demand that regulated exchanges return to offering contracts in all 50 states. Traders navigating these shifting jurisdictional boundaries often rely on Kalshi tools to track market availability.
Senate Hearing Highlights Jurisdictional Clash
The clash between federal mandates and state laws was a focal point during a Tuesday Senate Agriculture Committee hearing regarding CFTC nominees Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland. Lawmakers heavily criticized the agency's aggressive posture against state-level bans. Senator Tina Smith (D-MN) emphasized that jurisdiction over sports gambling unambiguously rests with states and sovereign tribes, noting that the CFTC immediately sued Minnesota and 11 other states after Minnesota passed a law banning prediction markets, according to reporting by Dustin Gouker at The Event Horizon.
During the same hearing, Senator Adam Schiff (D-CA) accused CFTC Chairman Michael Selig of deceiving the committee during his confirmation by promising to defer to the courts on whether event contracts constitute gambling. Instead, Schiff argued, Selig has actively filed briefs instructing courts and directed companies to ignore state geofencing orders. Both nominees declined to prejudge the active litigation, though Rowland expressed sympathy for the concerns raised by states and tribes. As the legal landscape fractures, the differences in regulatory compliance continue to shape the broader Kalshi vs. Polymarket dynamic, with federal courts increasingly backing state-level enforcement against federally licensed event contracts.